TryShadowing
Shadow YouTube. Speak English.
Home
Browse
Dictation
NEW
My Library
en
0
days
Sign in
Who’s Taking America’s Water? |… — Climate Town shadowing | TryShadowing
TryShadowing
Shadow YouTube. Speak English.
Home
Browse
Dictation
NEW
My Library
en
0
days
Sign in
Home
Browse
Climate Town
Who’s Taking America’s Water? | Climate Town
Who’s Taking America’s Water? | Climate Town
Climate Town
·
39:21 · Aug 14, 2024
Start Shadowing
0:00
0:00
Record
×1
1x
VI
EN
JA
KO
ZH
FR
PT
TH
IT
DE
IPA
Pronunciation scoring isn't supported on this browser — you can still record and listen back.
Hey,
I'm
here
in
Los
Angeles,
California.
Translating…
Turn on Record to capture your voice and get scored
Smart
Karaoke
Original
Line
1
/923
0:00
Hey, I'm here in Los Angeles, California.
0:02
It's a city full of people who are way hotter than me, but they're
0:05
almost all dead inside.
0:07
It's in the eyes.
0:08
There's just nothing in there.
0:10
Not unlike the LA River.
0:11
It's a bonafide movie star, but it's polluted to the core from decades
0:15
of chemical spills, pesticide
0:17
infused runoff, and the burned out rubber from 95
0:20
takes of this scene from Grease.
0:26
But if you're not from Los Angeles,
0:28
you might find yourself thinking,
0:29
"That doesn't look like a river at all."
0:31
This is a river, this is a river, river, dog, river.
0:34
But out here in the American West,
0:36
a historic drought has made it very hard for these lifeless hotties to remember
0:40
that this is almost
0:42
no water at all.
0:43
And it's not just Californians.
0:45
The more than 40 million
0:46
people in the American West served by the famously
0:49
overused Colorado River are being asked to conserve
0:52
this water by any means necessary.
0:54
Historic water cuts to multiple states.
0:56
Cutting off the water while you're brushing your teeth, taking shorter
1:00
Cut back on their water use.
1:02
Peeing in the shower?
1:03
That's going to save you a couple of flushes and save you a couple of gallons.
1:06
Get a weapon and fire it into your lawn.
1:09
But no matter how much water they conserve,
1:11
there's not enough to go around.
1:13
So, where is all the water going?
1:15
Well, if you look at the 1.9
1:17
trillion gallons of Colorado
1:19
River water consumed by people every year,
1:22
a very unfortunate trend occurs.
1:24
According to a study from 2020,
1:26
all the water people use for drinking,
1:29
swimming pools, watering their lawns,
1:31
slip and slides, and any other private consumption
1:33
accounts for just 12%
1:35
of the water use.
1:36
Golf courses, office parks, and all other businesses
1:39
are just 4% of water use.
1:42
And weighing in at 79%
1:44
of all the water we use
1:46
is agriculture, which is crops.
1:49
And that might make sense
1:51
if it was crops for people.
1:52
But the vast majority
1:54
of water we use in the American
1:56
West goes to grow food
1:58
that people do not eat.
2:00
56% of all the water in this river goes to animal agriculture
2:05
and one animal above all others.
2:07
So, who's taking all of America's water? The cow.
2:11
Not this cow in particular,
2:13
but the United States is home to 87.2
2:16
million cows and the food those cows eat requires
2:20
so much water it's creating a real
2:22
shitstorm for people who want that water for drinking,
2:25
running cities, making energy,
2:27
basically just stuff we need to do to live.
2:30
And it would be one thing if we were blasting
2:32
through our water supply
2:33
because the citizens of our great nation decided
2:35
that's how they wanted to use it.
2:37
But the rules for who goes thirsty
2:39
and who gets to flood a literal
2:41
desert were written over 100 years ago and are based entirely
2:45
on the unbreakable ironclad law of dibs.
2:49
They consider dibs so sacred
2:52
that a single family in California
2:54
whose grandfather happened to start a dairy
2:57
farm near Palm Springs in the 1920s
3:00
gets more water than the entire
3:02
city of Las Vegas.
3:04
The people in this part of California
3:07
get more Colorado River water than all of Arizona and Nevada combined.
3:12
And if that sounds like a stupid
3:14
way to manage a critical resource,
3:16
just wait until you hear about the foreign governments
3:19
who currently have the right to use an unlimited
3:22
amount of ground water from America's
3:24
deserts and are exercising
3:26
that right to send cow food back to their own deserts.
3:29
So, as our supply
3:30
of water is being decreased
3:31
by climate change, which it very much is,
3:34
and our demand for water is being increased
3:36
by a growing population
3:38
of both people and livestock,
3:40
we should probably find a way to be a little more efficient
3:42
with our water use.
3:43
And regardless of your feeling on cheeseburgers,
3:46
I think we can all agree that it's generally a good practice
3:49
to just pop the hood on how we're using one of our most critical
3:52
resources to see if there's anything that can be learned from it.
3:56
Hi, I'm Raleigh Williams,
3:57
a guy with a climate science and policy degree,
4:00
a little sparkle in my eye, and what I can only imagine is foot conjunctivitis.
4:04
And this is a video about who's taking all of America's water.
4:08
Welcome to Climate To understand
4:29
why we're so hell-bent
4:31
on growing animal food in America's
4:33
deserts, we got to go back to the thrilling
4:35
conclusion of the Civil War.
4:38
The US had just been hot glued back together,
4:40
and people were free to enjoy their beloved pastimes
4:43
of making horses run fast,
4:45
honky baseball, and uprooting the entire family and building a new life somewhere else.
4:51
But where to go?
4:52
Well, what about this part?
4:54
I mean, why the hell does nobody live there?
4:56
Besides the people who already live there, but I'm sure they'll move.
5:00
So, the US hired a guy named John Wesley Powell
5:04
to do a geological
5:05
survey, and they crossed their fingers hoping Powell would come back saying
5:09
there's a ton of water everywhere,
5:10
and everything's ready to pump and grow.
5:12
Powell spent two decades
5:14
studying the Colorado River
5:15
and the West overall,
5:17
and then came back to Congress in 1890
5:19
with this ripper of a map.
5:21
Truly, I look at this map.
5:23
Beautiful colors, incredible detail
5:25
in the breakdown of the watersheds.
5:27
Imagine trying to make this map
5:29
without computers or satellites or colored pencils.
5:34
It would be pert near impossible.
5:36
Unfortunately, Powell found that there was just not enough water to settle the West.
5:40
And if you wanted to get even a few people out there, it would
5:43
make more sense to create federal dams to stabilize
5:45
water access, and to define your political boundaries
5:48
by water flow regions
5:50
instead of by arbitrary state lines.
5:52
You know, cuz water is such a critical
5:55
foundation for life and all.
5:57
The indigenous people who already lived there knew that and had extremely
6:00
effective water conservation techniques
6:02
dating back to 10,000
6:04
BC, including sometimes being nomadic
6:07
because water comes and goes in the West
6:09
and you need to be able to follow it.
6:11
Unfortunately, that wasn't really going to fly with the settlers
6:14
who preferred to get hundreds of acres of their own private
6:17
land that no one else can touch, and you can't tell me there's not
6:20
unlimited water for my free land.
6:23
And as you can probably imagine,
6:25
the US government didn't listen to a single one of Powell's warnings and just
6:29
waved settlers West like a third-base
6:31
coach in an exciting
6:33
game of honky baseball.
6:34
Too soon for a callback?
6:36
I just said honky baseball.
6:37
You know what, cut this part.
6:38
And if you're watching this and you're thinking,
6:40
"Well, obviously this John Wesley Powell guy didn't know what the he was talking
6:44
about because I've got a cousin in Arizona
6:46
and they have a swimming pool in their backyard."
6:48
That's a reasonable thing to think.
6:50
But first, consider the phrase credit card debt
6:54
and let's keep going.
6:55
Among the places settlers flocked to was just the straight-up
6:58
desert, including the bone-dry
7:01
Imperial Valley, California, which gets just
7:04
3 in of rain on average per year
7:06
and has more sun in the winter
7:08
than any other place in the US.
7:10
It's also in the movies.
7:13
That's what you get. Welcome to Earth.
7:17
Up until 1901, the Imperial
7:20
Valley was a barren,
7:21
uninhabited place because of course it was.
7:25
It was the desert.
7:27
But nowadays, it looks like
7:32
That's because the US dug a canal
7:34
to divert water from the Colorado
7:36
River into the south side of the valley,
7:38
and the Imperial Valley was not alone.
7:40
The US government dammed and canaled
7:42
and borrowed whatever they wanted from the mighty Colorado
7:45
to suit the needs of the settlers
7:47
who wanted that water.
7:48
And since water was the single
7:50
most important resource for these thirsty
7:53
western settlers, they made it their absolute
7:55
beeswax to dibs as much water as humanly possible.
7:58
After all, this is
8:00
free water you get the rights to forever.
8:03
You would have to be
8:04
an idiot not to try to get as much as you possibly could.
8:08
And so a dibsing spree for the Colorado River commenced.
8:11
Farmers got a couple million gallons a year here, a couple million gallons a
8:14
year there, but I mean there's 2 trillion
8:17
gallons of usable water in that son of a
8:19
How could we possibly
8:21
run out of water?
8:22
He asked less than halfway
8:23
into a 30-minute meeting.
8:29
Our favorite publications, Grist, did some excellent reporting on this, link in the bio,
8:34
and found this quote from a 1960
8:36
US Supreme Court case.
8:38
I am morally certain that neither in my lifetime
8:41
nor in your lifetime
8:42
nor the lifetime of your children
8:44
and great-grandchildren will there be an inadequate
8:47
supply of Sat down with Secretary
9:36
of Commerce Herbert Hoover
9:38
and hammered out a deal that would split the river in half hamburger style
9:41
giving upper basin states 7.5
9:43
million acre feet per year
9:44
and lower basin states 7.5
9:46
million acre feet per year.
9:47
Now, I know you know obviously,
9:50
but an acre-foot is the amount of water it takes to submerge
9:53
one acre or about 3/4
9:55
of a football field
9:56
in one foot of water.
9:58
So, you know, kind of a lot of water.
10:00
An acre-foot is about gallons of water.
10:05
And the Colorado River Compact
10:06
dealt out 15 million of these little guys
10:09
to the seven states. Sounds great. One problem.
10:13
The Colorado River does not have that much water.
10:17
They drew up the Colorado
10:18
River Compact during some extremely
10:20
wet years and despite
10:21
knowing there were only 14
10:23
million acre feet or less for consumption,
10:26
they figured it would just be a problem for future
10:28
Americans to deal with. Haha, thanks, guys.
10:33
They also completely cut Mexico
10:34
out of the initial compact
10:36
only to attack them on later by inventing
10:38
a bunch of water that didn't really exist.
10:40
And also also, they didn't even pretend
10:42
to equitably include indigenous
10:44
people, but you probably already guessed that, didn't you?
10:47
Oh, and another problem.
10:49
Water rights are hierarchical,
10:51
which means senior rights holders get their entire
10:54
allotment before junior rights holders even get a drop.
10:57
And even if senior rights holders wanted to conserve water
11:01
and send the rest down the line,
11:02
they kind of can't.
11:03
Because water rights are subject
11:05
to a use it or lose it rule.
11:07
See, in an attempt to prevent people from dibsing a bunch of water
11:10
only to turn around and sell it to the highest bidder,
11:13
you'd only get to keep the rights to water that you actually use.
11:16
And if you think about this for an extra 10
11:19
seconds, you'll realize it's an excellent way to discourage water conservation.
11:23
If a farmer decides to use less water
11:26
or develop a less wasteful irrigation
11:28
technique, that farmer is rewarded
11:30
with having all of his extra water taken away forever.
11:35
Ah, you thought I wasted that water. Uh-uh, bucket.
11:38
Try to keep up.
11:40
Anyway, farmers were also banned from selling their unused
11:43
water allotment as part of the government's attempt to avoid water speculators.
11:47
So, if your dad's
11:48
dad moved to the desert and called dibs at the exact
11:51
right time, your family might now find itself with 84
11:55
billion gallons of water every
11:57
year and a strong incentive
11:59
to use every last drop.
12:01
And it is this little quirk in America's water law
12:04
that got so many desert dwelling farmers
12:06
into the cattle feed business. That's right.
12:10
It's time to talk about alfalfa.
12:13
Alfalfa is prized for having a lot of easily digestible protein.
12:17
And if you're trying to support a dairy cow blasting
12:19
out hot high protein
12:20
milk, it's a damn
12:22
fine option for feed.
12:23
Beef cows tend to eat a lot of other stuff, but they'll also suck
12:26
down alfalfa with the best of them when they get a crack at that good green.
12:30
Before researching for this video,
12:32
all my alfalfa knowledge was about this little
12:35
but I pushed all that information
12:36
out to make room for this alfalfa.
12:39
Now it's your problem.
12:40
As a crop, alfalfa
12:43
loves the sun and can grow for five to seven years with way deeper
12:47
roots than normal row crops.
12:49
Also, if you can keep the sun shining on it year-round,
12:51
you can get 10 to 12 harvests
12:54
per year out of the same plant.
12:56
But unfortunately, alfalfa also needs a lot of water.
13:00
So, you're probably thinking this is one of those classic tradeoffs.
13:03
Ratatouille loves to cook,
13:04
but he's got to be sneaky about it or else his little rat ass will get shot.
13:08
Alfalfa loves the blasting
13:09
sun, but it's got to be sopping
13:11
wet basically all the time.
13:13
So, you got to compromise, Wrong.
13:17
Yes, alfalfa is also grown in other less arid parts of the US,
13:21
but those places are nothing
13:23
compared to the yields you can get if you have two ingredients:
13:26
a full-on blasting desert sun year-round,
13:30
and a ridiculous amount of water that you would have to use.
13:34
They have so much water in that part of the desert
13:37
that a lot of alfalfa
13:38
fields have traditionally been flood
13:40
irrigated, which conveniently for us is exactly
13:43
what it sounds like.
13:44
You hook up a hose and make a fun little flood for your crop
13:47
friends until they're soaking in an inch or two of water.
13:49
Some of that water goes into the soil,
13:51
some floats up into the air, and some runs off into another farm.
13:55
Maybe all the way to the Salton
13:56
Sea, a body of water filled almost entirely
13:59
with excess irrigation water from the Colorado River.
14:02
And by the way, we're currently out on a farm in Long Island.
14:05
This is not the kind of farming
14:07
we're talking about in the video.
14:08
We mostly just wanted like
14:10
a farmy kind of background
14:12
so that it wouldn't bump too much with the other parts of the video.
14:15
This is a place called Young's Farm.
14:17
They do excellent work here.
14:18
Thank you so much for the location.
14:20
Now, pretend you're back in the American West.
14:23
Another benefit of alfalfa
14:25
is it can be grown year-round
14:27
alongside potentially higher-value seasonal crops.
14:30
Got a couple extra acres
14:31
and a bunch of water to use? Blast 'em, Jackson.
14:35
Alfalfa can also withstand short periods of no irrigation,
14:38
then pop right back.
14:39
So, you could drop the water demand in the summer,
14:41
then bring back the same stand of alfalfa into production when there's more water available.
14:46
It's honestly a pretty good crop.
14:48
It just requires a ton of water.
14:52
And uh not to ride his coattails
14:53
too hard or anything,
14:55
but my main man John Oliver did a whole Last Week Tonight about water
14:58
a couple of years ago
14:59
and found this excellent
15:00
clip from an Arizona alfalfa farmer interview.
15:03
Roll the clip of them rolling the clip.
15:06
Just listen to this farmer in Arizona
15:07
explaining why he chose to grow
15:09
a particularly water-intensive crop.
15:12
Well, I've just been farming it.
15:14
This alfalfa, you got to keep farming it to keep the water.
15:17
And that's why I was mainly doing it.
15:20
It was to hang on to the water.
15:21
In the Imperial Valley alone,
15:24
alfalfa fever has led to the projected
15:26
use of 2.6 million
15:28
acre-feet of water from the Colorado River this year.
15:31
And according to reporting from ProPublica
15:33
and the Desert Sun,
15:34
most of that water apparently goes to just 20
15:37
families in the valley who have such senior water rights
15:41
that they aren't subject to the same constraints as nearby cities.
15:44
ProPublica and the Desert Sun even made some excellent
15:47
graphics about it, and here they are right now.
15:54
That's just one section of the Colorado River.
15:57
If you look at the upper part of the river that includes Colorado,
16:00
New Mexico, Utah, and the one with the Horseshoe
16:02
everybody's parents are obsessed with.
16:04
That land is mine.
16:05
You see that fence? That's mine. That fence mine. This field's mine.
16:08
That fence down there, that's mine, too.
16:12
Spinning son of a
16:16
And in that region,
16:17
90% of agricultural water
16:20
is turned into cattle feed.
16:21
I'm sweating into my own eyeballs.
16:25
Yes, we do feed some cows for fun,
16:27
sure, but the vast
16:29
majority are fed so they can either blast
16:31
out milk or be mysteriously
16:33
killed and turned into beef.
16:35
And I know it seems like treating
16:37
an important resource like it's worth nothing and will never run out seems like
16:41
a strategy that wouldn't have a downside,
16:44
but folks, it has a downside.
16:47
As the population and farming operations
16:49
grow and they're removing more and more water for showering,
16:51
drinking, and growing crops
16:53
in the desert, we started writing checks that our asses couldn't cash,
16:57
and we simply do not have the water for the activities
17:00
we want to use it for.
17:01
The Colorado River and its reservoirs
17:03
have dwindled to alarmingly low levels. St.
17:06
George, Utah is running out of
17:08
Dry riverbeds, depleted reservoirs,
17:10
canals, and fallow fields.
17:12
And also, climate change has snuck into the party
17:14
and is making everything
17:16
worse in the back near the bathroom.
17:17
The worst mega drought in at least 1,200
17:21
Yeah, they say climate change has fueled wildfires
17:24
and threatened the economic security of farmers.
17:26
It's endangering the security
17:28
of energy and water resources
17:30
for nearly 6 million homes and businesses across seven states.
17:33
One study from UCLA
17:34
found that rising temperatures
17:36
between 2000 and 2021
17:38
have led to a loss of 30
17:40
million acre-feet of water
17:42
from the Colorado River Basin,
17:43
which has combined with a drought,
17:45
which is also probably tied to climate change,
17:48
to leave the massive
17:49
reservoirs along the Colorado dangerously, historically low.
17:53
The reservoirs are so low that even a massive
17:55
smash of snowpack over a winter or two doesn't come close to refilling the
17:59
reserves, which means this may not be an example of a classic
18:02
drought, this might be aridification.
18:05
While a drought is temporary
18:07
and we'd expect a full rebound,
18:08
aridification means the area
18:10
will be permanently drier
18:12
with less water available.
18:14
And while the American
18:15
West is particularly susceptible
18:17
to a drought, we certainly
18:19
don't have a monopoly on it.
18:21
And I don't want to hit you over the head with it, but that
18:23
means that the climate
18:25
might be Which means climate change. I'll say it. I'm crazy.
18:31
I'll say climate change right to your dang face.
18:34
I'll say it at dinner,
18:35
right to my uncle,
18:36
and we won't talk for 6 years.
18:38
But if the Colorado
18:39
River water rights are too complicated,
18:41
the federal rules around how much groundwater
18:43
you can pump out of private wells
18:45
are a whole lot simpler. There aren't any.
18:49
Groundwater is water that collects in giant
18:51
underground aquifers over the course of hundreds of thousands
18:54
or maybe even millions of years.
18:56
Regulation of groundwater is usually left up to the states,
18:59
but they tend to be pretty loose with the laws.
19:02
And that's not me editorializing.
19:04
States like Missouri literally
19:06
brag about having, quote,
19:07
the loosest water laws in the country,
19:10
where water users have the right to under most circumstances
19:14
use as much water as they would like and for whatever purpose they see fit.
19:18
Back in the Civil War days when honky baseball
19:20
was already starting to get boring, great callback.
19:23
Yes, the government didn't really understand
19:26
how or why groundwater flowed.
19:28
In modern days, we now understand that aquifers
19:31
take thousands of years to recharge.
19:33
But back then, we thought it was maybe unlimited infinity water?
19:38
I mean, it didn't even matter
19:40
time because groundwater was dozens
19:42
to thousands of feet below the surface.
19:45
Why make a law about water
19:46
that we didn't even have the technology to get to?
19:49
By the 1930s, our craftiest
19:51
engineers had figured out how to drill down and pump it out.
19:54
But instead of making laws to regulate
19:56
it, we had already established
19:58
the sort of no shirt, no shoes, no problem policy.
20:02
And to this day,
20:03
groundwater is free and unlimited in most places.
20:08
One of those places
20:09
is most of Arizona,
20:11
where you are free to pump as much water as you like
20:14
out of their underground
20:15
aquifers, which are doing just fine.
20:17
I'm sorry, I'm hearing that should be declining
20:20
at an alarming rate.
20:22
And it's here that we get a sense of just
20:24
how little of a
20:26
America gives about its water.
20:28
Because what do you think happens
20:30
when you pump too much water
20:31
out of an aquifer?
20:35
Uh-oh, did you just Google it? Cuz that's cheating.
20:38
And cheaters never win.
20:40
But also, if you went online to find a news article about groundwater,
20:43
you may have found more than you bargained for.
20:45
That's right, I'm talking about bias.
20:47
Lucky for you, there's Ground News.
20:49
Yes, sir, Ground News is an independent
20:51
website and app that gives you an easier and more data-driven
20:54
way to read your news.
20:55
Every story comes with a visual breakdown of the publication's
20:58
political leaning, reporting reliability,
21:00
and ownership, allowing you to see potential journalistic
21:03
conflicts before you're telling a room full of people that Rudy Giuliani
21:07
can do a kickflip.
21:08
You want an example?
21:09
Yeah, I bet you do.
21:11
Did you know that the Oklahoma State Superintendent
21:14
just mandated that the Bible
21:16
must be incorporated into public schools for kids from fifth grade
21:20
all the way through graduation?
21:22
Let's check it out.
21:23
Right away you can see that over 150
21:25
news outlets reported on the story.
21:27
Of these, 35% lean left while only 19% lean right. Huh.
21:32
You can also compare headlines
21:34
to see how bias can affect framing.
21:36
The Western Journal frames this as Oklahoma
21:38
righteously putting the Bible back in schools,
21:41
while National Zero focuses
21:43
on the Oklahoma education
21:44
secretary threatening to revoke teaching licenses
21:47
for not incorporating the Bible. Different.
21:49
Ground News also has my personal favorite feature,
21:52
the blind spot feed, where you can see stories that the publications
21:55
you usually read might not cover.
21:57
Did you hear about the Pope's new swimming pool?
22:00
Uh not that, but you know, stuff like that.
22:02
You got to check it out for yourself.
22:04
Ground News helps you think more critically
22:06
about how news is spreading
22:08
and who's probably reading it, which helps you better understand
22:11
our increasingly divisive world.
22:14
And that sounds pretty damn good to me.
22:16
And if you're thinking what I'm thinking,
22:17
I encourage you to check out Ground News.
22:20
And yeah, baby, we got a discount code for you. I'm talking ground.
22:24
dot news slash I think backslash,
22:28
but I've never really been able to tell the difference. climatetown.
22:30
That's the important part.
22:31
ground.news/climatetown or just click that link in the description
22:34
and get 40% off the Vantage level subscription,
22:38
which gives you access to every
22:40
single goddamn feature on the app.
22:42
That's a month, which has a well-known
22:47
$5 a month bias. Thank you.
22:58
And now, back to Climate
23:00
Town and the thrilling
23:02
answer to the question,
23:04
what do you think happens if you pump too much groundwater
23:07
out of an aquifer?
23:10
You run out of water.
23:11
And it doesn't come back.
23:13
The more water you pump out of the ground,
23:15
the lower and lower the water table gets.
23:17
This leads to a phenomenon
23:19
called subsidence, where land slowly caves in Hellmouth style.
23:24
The more you pump,
23:25
the deeper you have to drill your well,
23:26
until eventually you run out of water.
23:29
It's a lot like putting all your bills on a credit card.
23:31
It feels incredible for a while,
23:34
but sooner or later,
23:35
it's going to catch up with you.
23:37
And the way I know this
23:38
is because it's happening
23:39
right now in Arizona.
23:41
People in La Paz County, Arizona,
23:43
who used to have functioning
23:44
groundwater wells, are waking up to find that they now have a very deep,
23:48
very dry pipe in their yard.
23:50
Because let me tell you about the Almarai
23:53
Dairy from Saudi Arabia.
23:55
As of 2018, it has been illegal
23:57
to grow alfalfa in Saudi Arabia.
23:59
Without getting too far into it, Saudi Arabia pumped the
24:03
out of their groundwater
24:04
from the late 1940s
24:05
until a couple of years ago.
24:07
And in that time,
24:08
they used up approximately
24:09
80% of their fossil groundwater.
24:12
They needed to look elsewhere
24:13
for the most precious of resources,
24:15
and due to the United States' loose groundwater
24:18
laws, that meant buying land in Arizona
24:20
and just taking America's groundwater.
24:22
So, they bought 15
24:24
square miles of prime Arizona
24:25
desert, drilled deeper in the aquifer
24:28
than the retirees and farmers in the county,
24:30
and dangerously lowered the groundwater
24:32
level by pumping up as much water as they wanted for $0.
24:37
Freedom, it would seem, is free.
24:42
And if you're wondering how much water Saudi Arabia pulled out of the ground, you're not alone.
24:47
The Arizona State Land Department sent a memo to at least ask them to
24:51
measure how much water was getting pumped out, because they were worried about groundwater
24:55
depletion as a result of agricultural
24:57
leases in the Butler Valley,
24:59
but unfortunately, the Arizona
25:01
state government at the time wanted to be cautious
25:03
of tangling with a powerful company
25:05
and the metering request was denied.
25:07
But, I mean, come on.
25:09
How much water could Saudi Arabia possibly have taken?
25:17
And I don't presume to know how the people of La Paz County, Arizona feel about this.
25:21
But luckily, I don't have to because there's a recording of them explicitly
25:25
saying how they feel about this thanks to the top-tier
25:27
journalism by a publication called Reveal.
25:30
You're saying it's perfectly legal
25:32
for these people to come in here, drain
25:34
the aquifer, and the local people have to re-drill
25:38
their wells that they've lived there for years.
25:40
We got to move on.
25:42
But yes, it is it they're not breaking the law.
25:44
Now, Saudi Arabia shipping alfalfa back home sounds pretty bad
25:48
until you remember that the number
25:50
one exporter of alfalfa,
25:52
with more exports than all
25:54
other countries in the world combined,
25:57
yes, it's the United States.
25:59
It's not always the United States in sentences like that, but like
26:02
nine times out of 10 it is.
26:04
And yes, a ton of those exports come from the most water-constrained
26:08
parts of the Colorado River Basin.
26:10
You want to hear something really wild?
26:12
In the Imperial Valley, after they harvest that flood-irrigated
26:15
alfalfa for the 12th
26:17
time that year, 12th,
26:19
l f t h,
26:21
that's a obstacle course of a
26:26
Whatever, it's more expensive to send that alfalfa
26:29
to cows in another part of California
26:31
than it is to cram it onto a cargo ship and send it off
26:34
to two of the biggest alfalfa
26:36
importers in the world, China and Japan.
26:39
And if you're wondering how that could possibly
26:41
be cheaper, here's a fun little factoid
26:43
you can tell your friends.
26:44
The US imports more stuff from China than we export.
26:48
So, there's a constant
26:49
stream of shipping containers coming to America
26:52
full and going back empty.
26:54
China and Japan are eating an increasing
26:56
amount of beef and dairy,
26:57
but rather than use their own precious water resources,
27:00
they can buy and ship American
27:02
livestock feed like alfalfa
27:03
across the Pacific for next to nothing,
27:06
cramming those otherwise empty cargo ships
27:08
full to the brim with compressed alfalfa hay.
27:11
And I don't want to be overly dramatic,
27:13
but this basically amounts to exporting water.
27:17
Water that we apparently
27:18
really need in the arid West.
27:20
And I'm not being overly dramatic
27:23
because this is exactly
27:24
what a bunch of much smarter and more informed people than me have already said.
27:28
I'm just saying it way louder than them!
27:32
Also, big shout out to Arizona
27:35
water expert Professor Robert Glennon for all the help he gave us on this episode.
27:39
He wrote this incredible book Unquenchable,
27:41
you should totally read it, link in the bio,
27:43
as well as a bunch of other articles and another book.
27:46
How many books have you written?
27:48
Is it zero books?
27:50
Would zero be an accurate count?
27:53
I'm sorry, I don't know where that came from.
27:54
I think this sun is permanently cooking my brain.
27:58
Let's wrap this up.
27:59
The United States is currently in the middle of a serious
28:02
water crisis that we are treating very unseriously.
28:06
We haven't updated our Western water laws that we cobbled
28:10
together to help 1900s
28:11
era farmers settle water disputes without shooting each other, and now those laws have metastasized.
28:17
Our available river water is decreasing
28:19
due to climate change,
28:20
but rather than reward conservation,
28:22
we're incentivizing farmers to use all the water they possibly can.
28:26
Our ground water is being pumped out faster than it can be replenished,
28:30
but rather than regulate
28:31
it or even measure it, we're giving it away for free with a purchase
28:34
of a little bit of land.
28:36
Our credit card debt is coming due,
28:38
and our reaction is to continue spending.
28:42
So, what are we going to do about it?
28:44
Well, step one is to stop incentivizing
28:47
the misuse of water.
28:49
And in some ways, this is already starting to happen.
28:52
Arizona Governor Katie Hobbs has canceled
28:54
one of the leases Saudi Arabia was using to pump unlimited
28:57
groundwater and is set to terminate three more in the coming year.
29:01
Which seems like a win
29:02
until you remember that American companies
29:05
are doing the exact same thing.
29:07
I mean, even Arizona's
29:09
state pension fund has invested $175
29:12
million in a Wall Street company
29:14
that's buying up land in Arizona for groundwater access.
29:18
And the pension fund only stopped when some people found out and pushed them to divest.
29:23
So, yeah, state governments
29:25
need to rethink how they regulate groundwater.
29:27
And you can get involved by joining some of the local and state groups
29:31
that are pushing for stronger or any legislation.
29:34
Even pushing the government
29:36
to measure, not stop,
29:38
not cap, measure how much groundwater
29:41
is being removed would be a good start.
29:44
But a much more powerful
29:45
fix would be to readdress
29:46
the system of double stampy's
29:48
no or races water rights that got us into this situation
29:51
in the first place.
29:52
Unfortunately, this is not a simple thing to do because for the most part,
29:56
water rights holders are just farmers trying to make a living.
29:59
Sure, there are a few monster
30:01
mash sized farms, but there are thousands
30:04
of struggling farmers out there.
30:06
And if we charged them an extra million dollars for their water
30:09
or just took it away,
30:10
that would be a real dick move.
30:13
It would also be an excellent
30:14
way to starve America
30:16
because that's where the food comes from
30:19
and a lot of food is mostly water.
30:21
If you're tempted to think about this like a farmers
30:23
versus city problem and that farmers are taking too much water,
30:27
just remember they're not using that water for slip and slides, brother.
30:31
They're using it to grow crops and livestock
30:33
that people in cities eat.
30:34
Most farmers aren't wasting their water,
30:37
they're deciding what to grow based on what they can make from the market
30:40
and what the current water laws are.
30:42
But still, water conservation's
30:44
got to come from somewhere.
30:46
And if you're looking at the same charts that I am,
30:48
a pretty obvious place is cattle feed.
30:51
When it comes to the Colorado
30:52
River, if every single person and business in every major city shut off all
30:57
their water valves, you would only cut 17%
31:00
of the water demand.
31:02
But again, it's not that simple.
31:04
Unwinding the law of the river would constitute
31:07
a seismic shift in American agriculture,
31:10
and honestly, I have no idea how that would look.
31:13
But there are some actionable
31:14
steps we can take to address water shortages.
31:17
Most regulations require rights holders to allocate
31:19
all the water or none of it.
31:21
And loosening some of these archaic
31:23
policies could allow farmers to conserve their water use through more efficient practices
31:27
like drip irrigation, then sell their extra water.
31:30
The money from the extra water
31:32
could even go to help fund some of those expensive drip irrigation installations.
31:36
So, you know, that's pretty nice.
31:38
The Inflation Reduction Act has also earmarked a few billion dollars
31:41
to help with the Western water crisis,
31:43
and it seems like about a billion of that might go to pay farmers
31:46
to follow their fields to save water.
31:49
Is that the perfect solution?
31:50
I don't know, but it is something.
31:54
And while cities and industries
31:55
are just a small percentage
31:57
of water use in the West,
31:58
we're still talking about trillions of gallons.
32:01
That means conservation efforts like not demanding
32:04
every house in America
32:05
comes standard with a Kentucky
32:07
bluegrass lawn, aka one of the largest
32:09
irrigated crops in America.
32:11
Now, you may be saying,
32:12
"Well, grass isn't a crop.
32:14
We don't eat it." exactly.
32:17
Another way to conserve
32:18
is to install low-flow appliances
32:20
and fixtures in buildings and houses.
32:22
As insane as it sounds, the city of Las Vegas has actually been making
32:27
a huge effort to conserve their water, as are a lot of other cities in the West.
32:31
One study found that as population
32:33
grew by 24% in the 28 urban areas they looked at, overall
32:37
water usage dropped by 18%,
32:40
which is pretty cool.
32:42
And if you're looking to get involved in an organization
32:44
that works on these problems,
32:45
you are in luck, my friend.
32:47
Our buddies over at Climate Change Makers have put together a playbook that you
32:50
can use to contact your local representatives
32:52
to urge them to take action on water conservation
32:55
through the upcoming farm bill.
32:56
So, if you're looking for a policy
32:57
solution to push forward, check it out.
32:59
Link in the bio.
33:00
It's technically a description,
33:02
but I say bio, so
33:03
whenever I say either one just know that that's in the text below this video.
33:08
But the big mac father of all of them
33:10
is probably to stop demanding
33:12
and consuming so much meat and cheese.
33:15
And I know times are tough right now, and those two items account for
33:18
a lot of people's favorite food.
33:21
I'm not in charge of you.
33:22
You're the boss of your own body.
33:24
I will say that if the principles
33:26
of supply and demand are to be believed,
33:28
farmers wouldn't use as much water to grow cattle feed
33:31
if we didn't consume so much beef and dairy.
33:34
It takes literal hundreds
33:35
of gallons of water to produce a single
33:38
pound of either beef or cheese,
33:40
so a collective effort to reduce our consumption
33:42
would actually have a big effect.
33:44
And I don't know what that means for you.
33:45
Maybe it means going meat and dairy free for a few days a week,
33:49
or trying a plant-based
33:50
meat alternative, or any number of replacements
33:53
for the current status quo
33:55
of flooding a desert for cow food.
33:57
And in case you're thinking Americans
33:59
are just hardwired to eat beef,
34:01
and there's simply no way to change that,
34:03
I guess I would point you to the fact
34:05
that industry groups are constantly
34:07
spending money trying to convince America's
34:10
children to eat more meat.
34:12
And this should really be its own episode,
34:14
but if we all naturally
34:16
eat beef, then why are industry groups so hell-bent
34:19
on getting pro-meat propaganda into schools?
34:22
If everybody was just naturally
34:24
drinking a bunch of milk all the time,
34:26
why would the dairy industry
34:28
need to hire actual
34:29
director Michael Bay to make this insanely
34:32
high quality milk And that was the Vienna wood dancing D.
34:37
And now let's make that random call with today's $10,000 question.
34:41
Who shot Alexander Hamilton
34:43
in that famous duel?
34:46
All right, let's go to the phones and see who's out there.
34:51
Hello, for $10,000, who shot Aaron Burr. Excuse me? Aaron Burr.
34:58
Hello, hello, Aaron Burr. Aaron Burr.
35:03
I'm sorry, maybe next time. Got milk?
35:07
Good lord, that is an awesome commercial.
35:10
Imagine being so good at making commercials
35:13
that they give you the Transformers franchise.
35:15
You get way more into the characters of the robots this time. They're so good.
35:19
They're always doing the right thing.
35:21
They're always doing good.
35:22
And I think people like that.
35:24
And also for the kids out there,
35:25
there was a time when not everybody knew about the life of Alexander Hamilton.
35:30
Before Lin-Manuel Miranda, nobody
35:32
even knew that Alexander
35:33
Hamilton was a rapper.
35:35
And this is just my personal
35:37
opinion, man, but if everybody really liked milk,
35:40
you wouldn't have to make an ad about it. Milk is famous.
35:44
Everybody knows what milk is.
35:46
Just let the people decide if they want to drink milk.
35:48
Leave me alone, milk. Kramer!
35:53
What am I drinking? Milk? Oh, Conclusion music.
35:58
We're home free, baby.
36:00
Okay, if you take away just one thing from this episode,
36:03
it should be to think a little bit more about how the world uses its water.
36:07
Now, if you're concerned about your personal
36:08
water usage, it's a good idea to consider
36:11
all the ways you use water
36:13
and not just when you turn on the faucet
36:15
or blast your lawn.
36:16
Water used on your behalf is also a big factor,
36:19
and that's influenced by a lot of things, including what you eat
36:22
and some archaic ass laws from the 1900s
36:25
that you probably don't have a lot of control over.
36:28
Okay, that's the end of the episode.
36:30
I probably could have gone on for another hour about this, but every episode
36:34
has to end somewhere
36:35
and I guess this is that somewhere.
36:37
There are a ton of other climate issues with animal agriculture
36:40
and I swear to Christ we're going to get to them.
36:43
But we figured we'd start with water on account of how water
36:46
is the thing that makes all life work.
36:48
And speaking of water,
36:49
big thanks to Teal Lato
36:51
aka Western Water Girl for all of her help with the research on this episode.
36:55
If you're looking to learn more about the Western US water shortage,
36:58
you simply must check out her videos.
37:00
Seriously, no notes, 10 out of 10, go check them out.
37:03
Also, thanks so much to Youngs
37:05
Farm on Long Island for letting us get a bunch of farmy looking shots.
37:09
They're doing great work out there.
37:11
We also bought some pies on our way out and let me tell you
37:14
those pies kicked ass.
37:15
Ooh, and all this pie talk is probably got you thinking,
37:18
do we still have a Patreon page?
37:21
You better believe we do, but something has changed. Something has shifted.
37:25
That's right, we got an official Climate Town phone line.
37:28
And now, hot crackers,
37:30
if you're a patron,
37:31
you can call me.
37:32
Not all the time.
37:34
Not just any old time.
37:35
That would ruin my life, okay?
37:37
There's going to be specific
37:38
times you can call me and if you don't hit one of those times,
37:41
you can leave a message, okay?
37:43
It's supposed to be for fun. Don't with me.
37:47
All right, there's also a bunch of other fun perks on the Patreon page.
37:53
We've also got a ton of fun perks on the Patreon
37:56
page like behind the scenes footage, town halls, a Patreon
37:59
only Discord channel, discount
38:01
tickets to the live shows, and a bunch of other stuff.
38:04
The Patreon page is the backbone of Climate Town.
38:06
So if you like what we're doing and you want to support us, Patreon
38:09
is a great place to do it.
38:11
We've also got t-shirts.
38:12
They're made by a company called TS Designs in North Carolina
38:15
and sent to you by the good folks at Ethics Merch.
38:18
We made a whole episode about merch that you can check out, but to
38:21
sum it up, these are nice shirts that are made entirely
38:23
in the Carolinas with a fully transparent
38:25
supply chain that actually pays workers a living wage.
38:28
If you want one of our very nice t-shirts,
38:30
you can buy one using the link down below.
38:32
We've also got a podcast
38:34
called the Climate Town Area's Playbook hosted by me and my childhood
38:37
friend and Daily Show writer Nicole Conlan
38:39
and executive produced by Ben Bolt.
38:41
And we have a newsletter
38:42
that me and Climate Town writer director Matt Nelson write.
38:45
There's links to all that in the description below.
38:47
That's the end of the video
38:49
and I've been waiting quite a while to do this.
38:55
I have not tried marijuana.
38:58
Uh I have never used it at any time.
39:18
Did you hear that pop?
Like
Share
Climate Town
View all →
B2
Environment
Karaoke
18:20
Fast Fashion Is Hot Garbage | Climate Town
Climate Town
B2
Environment
Karaoke
20:59
The Suburbs Are Bleeding America Dry | Climate Town (feat. @NotJustBikes)
Climate Town
B2
Environment
Karaoke
8:45
Plastic Recycling is an Actual Scam | Climate Town
Climate Town
B2
Environment
Karaoke
31:39
Parking Laws Are Strangling America | Climate Town
Climate Town
B2
Environment
23:12
Who Actually Controls Gas Prices? | Climate Town
Climate Town
B2
Environment
Karaoke
31:03
How Oil Propaganda Sneaks Into TV Shows | Climate Town
Climate Town
B2
Environment
Karaoke
30:55
Joe Rogan Doesn't Understand Graphs
Climate Town
B2
Environment
Karaoke
27:50
Your Food Is Lying To You | Climate Town
Climate Town
Suggested videos
B2
Environment
Karaoke
18:20
Fast Fashion Is Hot Garbage | Climate Town
Climate Town
B2
Environment
Karaoke
20:59
The Suburbs Are Bleeding America Dry | Climate Town (feat. @NotJustBikes)
Climate Town
B2
Environment
Karaoke
8:45
Plastic Recycling is an Actual Scam | Climate Town
Climate Town
B2
Environment
Karaoke
31:39
Parking Laws Are Strangling America | Climate Town
Climate Town
B2
Environment
23:12
Who Actually Controls Gas Prices? | Climate Town
Climate Town
B2
Environment
Karaoke
31:03
How Oil Propaganda Sneaks Into TV Shows | Climate Town
Climate Town
B2
Environment
Karaoke
30:55
Joe Rogan Doesn't Understand Graphs
Climate Town
B2
Environment
Karaoke
27:50
Your Food Is Lying To You | Climate Town
Climate Town