TryShadowing
Shadow YouTube. Nói tiếng Anh.
Trang chủ
Khám phá
Chép chính tả
NEW
Thư viện
vi
0
ngày
Đăng nhập
How Oil Propaganda Sneaks… — Climate Town luyện shadowing | TryShadowing
TryShadowing
Shadow YouTube. Nói tiếng Anh.
Trang chủ
Khám phá
Chép chính tả
NEW
Thư viện
vi
0
ngày
Đăng nhập
Trang chủ
Khám phá
Climate Town
How Oil Propaganda Sneaks Into TV Shows | Climate Town
How Oil Propaganda Sneaks Into TV Shows | Climate Town
Climate Town
·
31:03 · 11 thg 2, 2025
Bắt đầu học
0:00
0:00
Ghi âm
×1
1x
VI
EN
JA
KO
ZH
FR
PT
TH
IT
DE
IPA
Chấm điểm phát âm chưa hỗ trợ trên trình duyệt này — bạn vẫn ghi âm & nghe lại được.
My
favorite
part
of
any
TV
show
Đang dịch…
Bật Ghi âm để được thu giọng và chấm điểm
Thông minh
Karaoke
Câu
1
/692
0:00
My favorite part of any TV show
0:02
or movie is when our guy just destroys some with the verbal ass whooping
0:07
of a lifetime.
0:08
You dropped 150 grand on a education you could have got for a $150
0:11
in lay charges at the public library.
0:14
Interested in selling my youngest daughter into slavery is sanctioned in Exodus 21:7.
0:18
In this building when the president stands, nobody sits.
0:22
Devastating.
0:23
And sometimes the damage extends beyond the screen.
0:26
Paul Giamotti talked about Merllo in the 2004 wine thriller Sideways.
0:31
And if they want to drink Merllo, we're drinking Merllo.
0:33
No, if anybody orders Merllo, I'm leaving.
0:35
I am not DRINKING ANY MERLLO.
0:37
AND IT SEEMS to have contributed to an actual decline in Merllo sales.
0:41
So when I saw a viral Tik Tok clip from the new show Land
0:44
Man featuring a crotchety Billy Bob Thornton spewing a bunch of weird lies about
0:50
wind turbines,
0:51
you know, it really bummed me out.
0:53
You want to guess how much oil it takes to lubricate thating thing
0:56
and it's 20-year lifespan.
0:57
It won't offset the carbon footprint of making it.
0:59
And don't get me started on solar panels
1:02
and the lithium in your Tesla battery.
1:03
And I'm not saying that TV needs to fact police their characters,
1:07
but I am worried
1:08
that the millions of people who saw the out of context clip might assume
1:12
that the incorrect statements of a fictional television character are actually very smart
1:18
and need to be spread far
1:19
and wide.
1:20
And luckily, spending a month of my life getting to the bottom of this
1:24
is fun and interesting to me for some reason.
1:26
Hi, I'm Raleigh Williams,
1:28
a guy with a climate science
1:29
and policy degree and exactly zero memorized Bible verses.
1:33
And this is an episode about how disinformation gets around the internet.
1:37
Welcome to Climate Town.
1:57
The show Land Man was co-created by Taylor Sheridan,
2:00
aka the guy who made Yellowstone and its various prequels and spin-offs.
2:05
If you don't know about those, ask your parents.
2:07
They've seen every episode.
2:09
That land isn't mine.
2:10
You see that fence?
2:11
That's mine.
2:11
That fence mine.
2:12
This field's mine.
2:13
That fence down there, that's mine, too.
2:17
Spinning some But we're not here to talk stone.
2:22
Landman stars Billy Bob
2:24
as an oil company guy who makes sure
2:26
that they have land to drill on
2:27
and that no one messes with their In a scene
2:30
that has since gone multi-platinum viral online,
2:33
Billy Bob dunks on a city slicking lady lawyer who's been bamboozled by big
2:38
green tech into believing
2:40
that renewable energy is somehow good.
2:43
They use clean energy to power the oil wells.
2:46
They use alternative energy.
2:48
There's nothing clean about this.
2:49
Please, Mr.
2:50
Oilman, tell me how the wind is bad for the environment.
2:54
Do you have any idea how much diesel they have to burn to mix
2:57
that much concrete or make
2:59
that steel and haul this out here
3:02
and put it together with a 450 ft crane?
3:04
And it's 20-year lifespan.
3:06
It won't offset the carbon footprint of making it.
3:08
And watching that back, you may have caught yourself thinking,
3:11
"Oh I actually don't know how much diesel they had to burn to mix
3:15
that much concrete.
3:16
I must be a idiot.
3:19
But here's the thing,
3:20
you don't have to know
3:21
because a bunch of very smart people have already figured it out
3:25
and it's called a life cycle assessment.
3:27
And the whole point is to account for the actual emissions over the lifetime
3:31
of a wind turbine
3:32
or solar panel when you factor in all the installation
3:36
and maintenance and they look like this.
3:41
And if we look real close at this one,
3:43
not only does a wind turbine offset the carbon footprint of making
3:47
and installing and eventually disposing of it,
3:49
but it will offset that carbon footprint in an average of 5.3 months.
3:54
And study after study comes to a similar conclusion.
3:58
It takes a few months to a couple of years to offset the lifetime
4:02
carbon footprint depending on a lot of factors,
4:05
including the ones that he's so concerned about in the land man speech.
4:09
Wind turbines spend the vast majority of their lives producing fully carbon-f free energy.
4:14
So that 20 years thing seems kind of super wrong.
4:19
But don't worry, there's more.
4:21
We have a 120year petroleum based infrastructure.
4:25
Our whole lives depend on it.
4:26
And hell, it's in everything.
4:27
That road we came in on, the wheels on every car ever made,
4:31
including yours.
4:32
It's in tennis rackets and lipstick and refrigerators and antihistamines. pretty much anything plastic.
4:38
Your cell phone case, artificial heart valves, soap, hand lotion, garbage bags, fishing boats,
4:45
you name it.
4:46
Every thing.
4:48
Now, a lot of that is just true.
4:49
Oil and gas are in every thing.
4:52
We started out lighting it on fire for energy, but over the past century,
4:56
we figured out how to weave it into every part of our lives,
4:59
and especially anything involving plastic, which is almost entirely made from oil and gas.
5:04
And this is a really common argument for why you should shut up
5:07
and let oil companies do whatever they want.
5:10
I mean, your socks are made of plastic
5:12
and we do use a ton of oil
5:14
and we are running out of it.
5:16
But let's just think about that argument for one extra second.
5:20
If oil and gas are such incredible tools for manufacturing
5:23
and it'll be really hard to find their replacement,
5:26
then shouldn't we conserve those things?
5:29
Shouldn't we stop trying to cram oil
5:31
and gas into socks
5:32
and water bottles and build millions of solar panels
5:35
and wind turbines so we can stretch our finite
5:37
and dwindling fossil fuel resources
5:40
as far as they can go?
5:44
But instead of doing that,
5:46
America is now extracting more oil
5:48
and gas than any other country on Earth ever.
5:51
Forget Saudi Arabia, forget Russia.
5:54
America is right now the first team allconerence number one Friday night lights touchdown
6:00
full eyes clear heart can't lose of oil
6:03
and gas boys.
6:05
My heart is full.
6:10
My heart's full.
6:11
And not to get too into the weeds here,
6:13
but oil in the US
6:14
and specifically Texas is getting harder to extract every year.
6:18
Land man is set in what's known as the Perian Basin.
6:21
We've been drilling for oil there for a hundred years.
6:23
And for the first 80 years,
6:25
it was just sitting in big accessible pools right below the surface,
6:29
waiting to blast out the moment a Beverly Hillbilly tripped over it.
6:32
But that stuff is basically all gone.
6:34
And for the past couple of decades,
6:36
the main way to get that good old French Kevin is by fracking,
6:40
aka blasting the out of the shale rock, pumping it full of sludge,
6:44
and sucking up tiny droplets of trapped oil and gas.
6:47
Not only is fracking more labor intensive and costly,
6:50
but it also requires exponentially more drilling
6:53
and infrastructure since fracking wells deplete much faster.
6:57
And on top of that, we've already fracked the juiciest,
7:00
oiliest parts of the perian,
7:01
so we're getting less bang for our buck as the years go on.
7:05
But instead of conserving our fossil fuels or god forbid regulating them,
7:10
we are sucking them out of the ground
7:11
and putting them into every thing we can think of
7:15
because the free market is always right.
7:18
Technically, in this case, the free market was subsidized by the federal government,
7:22
which essentially meant they gave taxpayer money to private companies to develop fracking technology.
7:27
But who's counting?
7:28
Suddenly, America's like the biggest oil producer
7:31
and the biggest g
7:32
that was me people.
7:33
Oh, I just want you to So, and what the hell?
7:36
We're already here.
7:37
Let's do one more.
7:38
If the whole world decided to go electric tomorrow,
7:41
we don't have the transmission lines to get the electricity to the cities.
7:45
It would take 30 years if we started tomorrow.
7:48
We definitely do need major electric grid updates in the US and the world.
7:53
In the US in particular,
7:54
we have an insanely peacemeal patchwork of transmission lines built by thousands of independent
8:00
utilities who are mostly focused on local service without really thinking about how the
8:04
whole country fits together.
8:06
But if Billy Bob is worried about new construction,
8:09
he is in the wrong business
8:11
because oil and gas requires an incredible amount of infrastructure.
8:15
I guess Billy Bob's character just draws the line at infrastructure
8:19
that doesn't involve oil
8:20
and gas.
8:21
Whatever the case, it's inconsistent.
8:24
And also, we don't need to start working on this tomorrow.
8:27
We're already working on it.
8:28
The world already spends around half a trillion dollars per year on electric grid
8:33
and storage.
8:33
And there are lots of viable options for upgrading the grid
8:37
and transitioning to clean energy in the next 10 to 15 years.
8:40
A task, I will add,
8:42
that would be much easier
8:44
if fossil fuel companies would stop actively blocking progress on renewable energy
8:49
and grid updates.
8:50
But you don't have to take my word for it.
8:52
Take it away, hidden camera footage of Exxon Mobile lobbyist Keith McCoy.
8:57
Did we aggressively fight against some of the science?
9:02
Uh, yes.
9:03
Did we join some of these shadow groups uh to work against some of
9:09
the early efforts?
9:10
Yes, that's true.
9:11
But there's nothing there's nothing illegal about that.
9:14
You know, we were looking out for our investments.
9:16
We were looking out for our shareholders.
9:19
Huh.
9:20
And speaking of Exxon,
9:21
there was one last little throwaway line that we should take a look at.
9:25
Who owns them?
9:26
Oil companies.
9:27
We use them to power the wells.
9:29
And believe me, if Exxon thought theming things right there were the future,
9:33
they'd be putting them all over the goddamn place.
9:36
Okay.
9:36
What the is this argument?
9:37
If wind turbines worked, where are all the wind turbines?
9:41
YOU'RE SURROUNDED BY WIND TURBINES.
9:43
THAT'S WHY YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT THEM.
9:44
THERE'S 15,000 wind turbines in Texas.
9:48
LAWYER LADY SAW A BUNCH OF wind turbines
9:51
and asked you about them
9:52
AND YOU SAID,
9:53
"OH YEAH, THE OIL COMPANIES own them.
9:55
WHAT ARE YOU talking about?"
9:58
Okay, number one, a ton of oil companies are putting them up all over
10:02
the goddamn place,
10:03
like BP and Shell and Total.
10:06
To I think they only name checked Exxon cuz they're the most recognizable oil
10:10
company that isn't diving in on renewables.
10:13
And number two, Exxon's an oil company.
10:16
That's what they're good at.
10:17
I mean, they've tried other stuff to see if they can expand their horizons,
10:21
profits.
10:22
But their bread and butter is oil, and now I'm hungry. it.
10:27
Think about it this way.
10:28
Spaghetti is a fantastic food item,
10:30
but no matter how many times I try to order it from McDonald's,
10:33
they refuse to serve it to me.
10:35
They make burgers and fries.
10:37
They'll try a salad, and for about a month in 2023,
10:40
they murdered about 30% of Gen Z with Grimace' Purple Poison.
10:44
But the absence of a mixed spaghetti on their menu does not mean spaghetti
10:48
isn't a viable food.
10:50
They just love burgers.
10:52
Like Exxon loves oil.
10:54
I love gold.
10:57
OKAY, but that clip would be perfect if he said oil.
11:00
I love oil.
11:02
Perfect.
11:03
Whatever.
11:03
The part of this
11:04
that really gets my apples is
11:06
that none of these arguments are new.
11:08
The whole monologue reads like a Now that's what I call climate denial's greatest
11:13
hits album.
11:14
These exact anti-renewable pro- oil talking points have been tested
11:18
and repeated for years,
11:19
and the ones that performed the best with the general public got repeated again.
11:24
This whole you owe modern society to oil
11:26
and gas argument pops up in advertisements,
11:29
nature documentaries, the Epcot Center, Facebook memes, even children's books.
11:34
I literally have a children's book written by an oil
11:37
and gas lobby group
11:38
and distributed to public schools
11:41
that uses the same oil
11:42
and gas are in everything angle.
11:45
And it's not a secret who's been pushing this narrative.
11:48
For decades, fossil fuel companies and their many,
11:51
many industry lobby groups have spent millions upon millions of dollars on disinformation campaigns
11:57
and PR stunts and advertisements,
12:00
even influencer marketing campaigns.
12:02
There's a gaggle of articles you can read about this, but in my opinion,
12:06
you should start with the drilled podcast from Amy Westervelt.
12:09
There's a link in the bio,
12:10
but here's a little taste to wet your whistle.
12:13
Exxon as a company was putting ads in the newspaper
12:17
that were contrary to the research
12:19
that they were paying us to be doing.
12:21
So, this is an experiment in shifting public opinion away from urgency.
12:26
The TLDDR is that oil
12:28
and gas companies decided
12:29
that the best defense is a good offense.
12:31
And they've spent years chumming the waters with disinformation to convince the public of
12:36
everything from natural gas is clean to wind turbines are a bunch of dirty
12:41
gasg guzzling bird assassins.
12:43
They're noisy.
12:44
They kill the birds.
12:46
You want to see a bird graveyard?
12:48
You just go take a look.
12:49
A bird graveyard, go under a windmill someday.
12:53
You'll see more birds than you've ever seen ever in your life.
12:56
And it's finally time to get to the bottom of how this clip got
13:00
into an episode of Land Man
13:01
that otherwise had nothing to do with wind turbines.
13:04
Because folks, I think I figured it out
13:07
and I will tell you
13:08
because I like you
13:09
and I want you to have a satisfying ending to this video.
13:13
First things first, it wasn't an oil industry executive who secretly
13:17
and carefully wrote this out
13:18
and then slipped it into a script
13:20
so that Billy Bob would pop off about renewable energy.
13:23
So maybe it was Billy Bob himself.
13:25
I mean, after all, his performance was a little too perfect.
13:28
And he is from Hot Springs, Arkansas,
13:30
a mere 2-hour drive from the location of Arkansas's first major oil discovery,
13:35
a little town called Stevens, Arkansas, population 770.
13:40
So maybe Billy Bob just had an axe to grind for years,
13:43
and he wrote that monologue himself to settle a score.
13:46
I mean, after all, he did write, direct,
13:49
and star in an inexplicably fantastic movie, Slingblade,
13:53
where he played an intellectually challenged man,
13:55
and somehow it still holds up 30 years later.
13:58
So, we decided to watch some press interviews of Billy Bob for the show
14:01
Land Man to see what there was to see.
14:04
And by the way, this, as you can see,
14:06
this is not like a preaching thing about oil is awesome.
14:09
It's the ins and outs, ups and downs, the good, the bad,
14:13
and the ugly of the oil business.
14:14
It's not politicized or anything like that.
14:16
And that's basically how every interview went.
14:18
He's not trying to forward a personal agenda other than trying to pull off
14:22
wool hat under fedora
14:23
but make it pirate.
14:25
And if that's his personal agenda, sign me up.
14:28
No, obviously I'm just kidding.
14:30
He looks insane.
14:31
But then we found out
14:32
that Landman was actually based on a podcast called Boomtown.
14:36
And Christian Wallace, the creator and host,
14:38
was not only on set for a lot of the Land Man filming,
14:41
he's an executive producer and co-creator on the show.
14:45
Aha, we found the source.
14:48
But then we listened to all 11 episodes of Boomtown,
14:52
and it was really good.
14:54
Christian worked in the Perian as an oil rough neck himself,
14:57
and he'd been a writer for Texas Monthly for a few years before launching
15:00
the podcast.
15:01
And like a lot of his previous work,
15:02
Boomtown focuses on the less well-covered human stories. woven into the oil industry.
15:08
The often brutal reality of an industry
15:10
that might pay well
15:11
when times are good
15:12
and then disappear completely
15:13
when the price of a barrel of oil drops below the desired profit margin.
15:17
And a lot of
15:18
that oil and gas work comes with a ridiculously high degree of danger.
15:22
And some of these stories make it right into Landman.
15:25
This is a spoiler, so I guess watch out.
15:28
But at the end of the first episode,
15:30
three members of the same family die in a single oil field accident,
15:34
just like in the fourth episode of Boomtown.
15:36
But when it comes to climate change or oil's place in the world,
15:39
Christian's work on Boomtown sounds nothing like the Billy Bob speech.
15:43
There is, of course, increasing pressure to move away from fossil fuels.
15:47
Renewable energy is increasingly competitive.
15:49
It's possible that the world will turn its back on oil long before the
15:53
last drop is sucked from the perian.
15:55
One truth that's held steady for nearly a hundred years is this.
15:58
In the Perian, the next bust is always around the corner.
16:02
Really of the entire monologue,
16:04
there's only one line that actually sounds like it came from boom town,
16:07
which again is a podcast mostly about the horrible choices
16:11
and dangers of working anywhere near an oil field in West Texas.
16:15
Getting oil out of the ground is the most dangerous job in the world.
16:18
We don't do it cuz we like it.
16:19
We do it because we run out of options.
16:21
So, if those classic corporate oil industry PR talking points didn't come from the
16:26
guy who's the Perian Basin oil expert
16:29
and co-creator of the show,
16:31
where did they come from?
16:33
To answer that, we'd have to go all the way down to the bottom.
16:37
But first, a ad.
16:39
Oh it's a cliffhanger.
16:41
If you're familiar with the internet,
16:43
you'll know you shouldn't blindly believe everything that pops up in your feed.
16:47
Lucky for you, there's Ground News.
16:49
Ground News is an independent website
16:51
and app whose whole deal is promoting media literacy
16:54
and keeping you from falling into algorithmically generated conspiracy rabbit holes.
16:58
By aggregating the world's news in one place,
17:00
Ground News provides a data-driven way to compare coverage
17:03
and stay informed with visual breakdowns of each publication's political leaning,
17:07
reporting reliability, and ownership, allowing you to spot journalistic conflicts before they happen.
17:12
Like those freaky little milk kids from Minority Report.
17:15
But I know what you want, an example.
17:17
Let's take a look at Trump's recent decision to pause offshore wind development.
17:21
It looks like about 30 news sources have covered the story,
17:23
primarily leaning center or left of center,
17:26
and only a single right-leaning publication has written about it.
17:29
They focused heavily on Trump's, I don't know,
17:32
interesting beliefs that wind turbines are evil bird killing machines
17:35
that cut the value of your house in half.
17:37
A little perusal through the other articles ground news aggregated reveals another side of
17:41
the story.
17:41
The environmental impacts of kneecapping a source of non-carbon energy. different in a way
17:47
that doesn't seem totally random.
17:49
But my favorite ground news feature is the blind spot feed where you can
17:52
see the stories the publications you usually read might not cover.
17:56
Ground news helps you think more critically about how news spreads or doesn't spread.
18:00
And if you're trying to wrap your head around how our world keeps getting
18:03
more and more divided,
18:04
I highly encourage you to check it out.
18:06
And you know what?
18:07
Just cuz I like you.
18:08
You, yes I'm talking to you,
18:10
get an exclusive 40% off discount on the Vantage level subscription
18:14
that gets you access to every single goddamn feature on the app,
18:18
including bias breakdowns, ownership tracking, and the blind spot feed.
18:22
Just click the link in the description
18:23
or scan the QR code that's right on the screen to head to ground.news/climatetown
18:28
to get started.
18:29
That's ground.news/climattown for the full story and 40% off.
18:34
It's a screaming deal.
18:36
And now back to Climate Town
18:39
and the answer to how the oil propaganda got into the television show.
18:45
And we're back.
18:46
Next stop, the very bottom.
18:48
How strange is it
18:49
that we put like an a monetary value on actual life itself.
18:56
Wow.
18:56
It's a just such a strange strange concept.
19:03
Yeah.
19:03
Did you see that guy accidentally hit that moose with his car?
19:05
No.
19:06
Holy Jamie.
19:07
Pull that video up.
19:08
That's right.
19:09
I listened to an episode of the Joe Rogan Experience.
19:12
Specifically, episode 283, a full 3
19:16
and a half hourong interview with Land Man's other co-creator
19:20
and only credited writer,
19:22
Taylor Sheridan.
19:23
And guess what I heard?
19:25
That would make sense to me why the government would keep
19:28
that information from people.
19:29
Because if we found out
19:30
that people were essentially just a vessel of souls
19:33
and that we are essentially designed to give birth to artificial intelligence.
19:38
Yeah, it was a lot of that.
19:40
Like a lot a lot.
19:42
At one point, Joe Rogan is pretty sure
19:44
that Tucker Carlson has evidence for the existence of aliens.
19:48
Except they're not aliens.
19:50
They're angels and demons who are farming human souls
19:54
because these angel aliens eat AI.
19:57
And I'm not joking.
19:59
That's really what's in THIS EPISODE.
20:01
MY GOD, HOW IS THIS ONE OF AMERICA'S MOST POPULAR PODCASTS,
20:05
but about 49 minutes into this episode,
20:07
we gain some really interesting insight into the land man script.
20:11
Nothing makes me crack up more than the stop oil people
20:14
when they're blocking the highway with clothes made with oil.
20:19
Like they have This is This is This is one of my like drive
20:23
me.
20:23
It's insane.
20:25
I'm making I'm making a TV show about this right now.
20:27
Yeah.
20:27
Called Land Man with Billy Bob Thornton.
20:29
Oh, wow.
20:29
About the oil industry and about energy.
20:31
Interesting.
20:32
Well, let's not jump to any conclusions here.
20:34
I mean, he was nominated for an Oscar for writing Hell or High Water.
20:38
Maybe let's give, you know, there's this debate about climate change,
20:41
which by the way, climate's always changing.
20:43
It was changing before we showed up.
20:44
We're more likely to to run out of oil before we find its pure
20:48
replacement.
20:48
I mean, look, let's look at all the on your table made out of
20:52
oil.
20:52
The headphones, the soles of my shoes.
20:54
Yeah, everything.
20:54
Yeah, the socks I'm wearing, everything.
20:56
And there it is right there.
20:58
It's the Billy Bob monologue, but worse.
21:01
It seems like Taylor Sheridan has heard oil lobby talking points, remembered them,
21:06
and then wrote his own version for Land Man.
21:08
But as we listen to these guys talk for another 2 hours,
21:12
we get to something even more telling.
21:15
But people don't understand, you know, they're mandating all these electric vehicles in California.
21:19
Mhm. 75% of California's uh electricity comes from fossil fuels.
21:25
Um about 15% comes from wind
21:28
and alternative energy and
21:30
then they still get a little from nuclear.
21:32
This one is wild to me.
21:34
He's not even close on those numbers.
21:37
He's doing a Goodwill Hunting style monologue,
21:39
but he doesn't know any of the actual stats.
21:42
I mean, he's a good writer
21:43
and his instincts tell him he needs to say some numbers there,
21:46
so he just kind of makes some up and he's way off.
21:51
According to the actual numbers from the California Energy Commission,
21:54
renewable and no carbon energy in 2023 clocked in at 58% with fossil fuels
22:00
coming in at 42%.
22:02
Which is right around half of what Taylor Sheridan said.
22:06
Weirdly, he gave wind power too much credit in California
22:09
and then forgot about solar generation.
22:12
And I mean, if I had to speculate,
22:14
I might guess that because Taylor lives in Texas,
22:17
where they do get a big chunk of their electricity from wind,
22:20
he assumed maybe it'd be similar in California,
22:22
so we rifted some numbers that would support the thing he wanted to say,
22:26
which again was wrong, but it sounded pretty good.
22:29
I actually have a podcast called The Climate Deniers Playbook where I look at
22:34
old climate denial talking points with my co-host Nicole Conlin
22:37
and Joe Rogan and Taylor Sheridan hit like 75% of the talking points.
22:42
Every one of their predictions has always been wrong.
22:44
I mean, if you go back to Al Gore's a kill supposed opposed to
22:48
no snow by 2006
22:50
or something,
22:50
all All wrong.
22:51
Let's just say we took a corner of Utah
22:54
and we just solar panled
22:55
that.
22:55
Guess what?
22:56
We can't do get it anywhere.
22:57
We talk about things that warm the planet.
22:59
Yeah, that did a lot of warming for sure.
23:01
I've never heard no one's mentioned the half a thousand nuclear bombs we set
23:07
off.
23:07
And for the record,
23:08
I don't think these two dudes are taking bribes from the oil industry.
23:12
I just think that they are repeating stuff
23:14
that they've heard without actually checking to see
23:17
if it's true.
23:18
They're basically sharing a Facebook meme except they have massive audiences,
23:23
a dozen television shows, and access to Billy Bob Thornton,
23:27
and they're doing it in a deeply unself-aware way.
23:31
Cuz I can't stand to pay money
23:32
and have somebody preach to me their ideas.
23:35
We're in a weird time where everybody has a say,
23:38
and I don't think everybody should be able to talk.
23:40
It's like I mean everybody should be able to talk
23:42
but through social media
23:44
that gets just broadcast in mass to the world
23:49
and you get these groups of people
23:51
that they huddle up in these echo chambers
23:54
and they duke it out.
23:55
I just read something in the last day
23:57
or two that and I'm going to get it wrong
24:03
but 1937 is closer to 1984 than 2023 is 84.
24:08
He did get it wrong,
24:09
but not because he's being paid off by big number.
24:12
Because it's a thing he heard one time and it sounded right to him,
24:16
so he repeated it.
24:17
And I get it.
24:18
We all want to be Goodwill hunting.
24:20
But if you're trying
24:21
so hard to own the libs
24:23
that you're making up to reinforce some propaganda you heard,
24:27
you're not Goodwill hunting.
24:29
You're the ponytail guy.
24:31
And while I can't say for sure where Sheridan heard all this stuff the
24:34
first time,
24:35
it seems exceedingly likely
24:37
that we can eventually trace it all back to the fossil fuel companies who
24:40
have been spending millions of dollars to spread these messages
24:44
as far and wide
24:45
as they could.
24:46
And frankly, it was a great plan.
24:49
Oil executives in the 80s didn't have to kidnap a young Taylor Sheridan
24:53
and force feed him lies about wind turbines
24:56
so he would grow up to write a snappy monologue to poison the well
24:59
against renewable energy.
25:01
They just made a big big vision board
25:03
so they could capture
25:04
as many mines as they possibly could.
25:07
And one of the mines happened to be this guy spinning some
25:12
So what are we going to do about it?
25:14
Well, the first step is to get more informed about climate disinformation.
25:19
Incredible journalists have built careers investigating and breaking stories and writing about disinformation,
25:25
and you should read their work
25:26
and follow them on social media
25:28
and support them whenever possible.
25:29
We put a list of some of our favorites in the description.
25:32
Seriously, check them out.
25:34
The sad fact is that there's a lot of out there,
25:37
and it's not obvious
25:38
that whatever you're reading
25:39
or listening to or watching is accurate.
25:42
It isn't obvious how long a wind turbine takes to work off its carbon
25:46
debt or what California's electrical grid mix is.
25:49
If I hadn't just done a video about natural gas,
25:52
I might never have realized
25:54
that Sheridan's very confident rant was actually a sort of fossil fuel fanfiction.
26:00
I mean, look at this chart.
26:02
Looks legit.
26:03
It's all I just made up a bunch of numbers.
26:05
It's that easy.
26:06
And judging by recent events, the level of is going to increase.
26:11
In the proud tradition of a billionaire with a social media network,
26:15
Mark Zuckerberg released a video about how Facebook will be rolling back factchecking.
26:19
So, arming yourself with a better understanding of how to spot propaganda is a
26:24
really good idea.
26:25
Uh-oh.
26:26
Did I just spend a bunch of time pushing a narrative
26:28
that learning about climate disinformation was good
26:31
and then come to a self-serving conclusion?
26:34
You bet your apples I did.
26:36
I learned it from the best.
26:38
Whoa, location change.
26:39
That's right.
26:40
I'm in sunny San Francisco for something completely unrelated to this episode,
26:44
but I figured this would be a good place to tell you about Climate
26:47
Town hats.
26:48
But not just any old hats.
26:50
We're not going to get got by Billy Bob on this one.
26:52
These hats contain no plastic.
26:55
We've wanted to make hats for a while,
26:57
but it turns out
26:57
that basically any hat
26:58
that looks like this contains a ton of plastic.
27:02
Everying thing.
27:03
But then our partners over at Ethics Merch found a company called Rustec.
27:07
Ruststeck was started by two brothers, Clayton and Miles.
27:10
They have no regard for their own personal safety.
27:13
And like a lot of outdoorsy folks, they care about the planet,
27:17
specifically the snow parts.
27:19
But unfortunately, outdoor gear and apparel is basically all plastic, like this or this.
27:25
So they set out to make outdoor stuff from natural materials like wood
27:29
and cork and cotton
27:31
and hemp.
27:31
And that led them to make this hat.
27:33
But then they realized
27:34
that even though they'd worked
27:36
so hard to promote natural materials,
27:38
the hat was still mostly plastic.
27:41
So they went back to the drawing board
27:43
and they created a design
27:44
that is 100% natural materials.
27:47
And here it is.
27:48
They replaced the normally plastic brim with a thin layer of bamboo covered in
27:52
cork.
27:52
And they worked with a factory in Canada to replace everything plastic
27:56
and crank out hats.
27:58
Now, at this point, you might be wondering, are the hats actually any good,
28:02
though?
28:04
Yes.
28:04
Yes, they are.
28:06
Now, honestly, we were a little nervous
28:07
that it would feel too different from a normal plastic hat,
28:10
but then we spent the past four months wearing the out of them,
28:14
sweating into them, washing them, waving them around, and throwing them on the ground,
28:18
and stomping on them like an angry little league baseball coach.
28:21
And we can confidently say we like these hats so much,
28:24
we decided to make our own.
28:26
So, here we are in this truly beautiful place introducing the first ever Climate
28:31
Town hat.
28:32
And they look like this.
28:34
Nice.
28:34
The art was actually really easy to make because we didn't do it.
28:38
We worked with this incredible artist named Jeff L Palato from Planet People Studio
28:43
who created this slick design
28:44
that combines the official Climate Town Eagle with hat.
28:48
Very nice and not at all plastic.
28:51
And I know almost every othering thing in the world still has plastic in
28:55
it.
28:55
We just wanted to look into some alternatives.
28:58
And one of those alternatives is brought to you by the good folks over
29:01
at Rustc.
29:02
God bless those outofcontrol allnatural lunatics.
29:05
So if that sounds like something
29:07
that you would like to put on your head
29:08
or the head of a loved one,
29:10
by all means get yourself an official Climate Town hat.
29:13
Link in the bio.
29:15
Pitch over.
29:16
And that's the end of the episode.
29:18
Thank you so much for watching.
29:20
As always, the best way to support us is through our Patreon page.
29:23
We got behind the scenes clips, bloopers, access to the Climate Town landline.
29:28
You can just call me directly and I have to answer.
29:31
I'm legally obligated.
29:32
We got early tickets to our live shows, monthly video calls,
29:35
and so much more.
29:36
Patreon is the glue that holds the whole channel together.
29:39
So, if you want to see more of this,
29:41
either in a general sense or an acute extended scene kind of sense,
29:46
we got them both.
29:47
What a deal.
29:48
We've also got a kick-ass newsletter written by Climate Town writer director Matt Nelson
29:52
and me.
29:53
And we've also also got a bitching podcast called The Climate Deniers Playbook,
29:58
co-hosted by my friend
29:59
and daily showriter Nicole Conland
30:01
and executive produced by Ben Bolt.
30:03
And if you're feeling like you want to check out Landman,
30:06
let me strongly recommend that you first listen to all of Boomtown instead.
30:11
And after you hear all 11 episodes,
30:13
if you still want to hear what Taylor Sheridan has to say about the
30:16
oil industry,
30:18
then I guess go right ahead.
30:20
All right, that's the end of the episode.
30:22
Remember, don't believe everything you see on a screen.
30:25
A lot of those guys are just reading off of qards.
30:29
Dramatic pause.
30:32
Okay.
30:33
Okay.
30:34
I have not tried marijuana.
30:37
Uh I have never used it at any time.
31:00
Did you hear that pop?
31:01
Goodbye.
Thích
Chia sẻ
Climate Town
Xem tất cả →
B2
Môi trường
Karaoke
18:20
Fast Fashion Is Hot Garbage | Climate Town
Climate Town
B2
Môi trường
Karaoke
20:59
The Suburbs Are Bleeding America Dry | Climate Town (feat. @NotJustBikes)
Climate Town
B2
Môi trường
Karaoke
8:45
Plastic Recycling is an Actual Scam | Climate Town
Climate Town
B2
Môi trường
Karaoke
31:39
Parking Laws Are Strangling America | Climate Town
Climate Town
B2
Môi trường
23:12
Who Actually Controls Gas Prices? | Climate Town
Climate Town
B2
Môi trường
Karaoke
30:55
Joe Rogan Doesn't Understand Graphs
Climate Town
B2
Môi trường
Karaoke
27:50
Your Food Is Lying To You | Climate Town
Climate Town
B2
Môi trường
Karaoke
21:27
It’s Time To Break Up With Our Gas Stoves | Climate Town
Climate Town
Video gợi ý
B2
Môi trường
Karaoke
18:20
Fast Fashion Is Hot Garbage | Climate Town
Climate Town
B2
Môi trường
Karaoke
20:59
The Suburbs Are Bleeding America Dry | Climate Town (feat. @NotJustBikes)
Climate Town
B2
Môi trường
Karaoke
8:45
Plastic Recycling is an Actual Scam | Climate Town
Climate Town
B2
Môi trường
Karaoke
31:39
Parking Laws Are Strangling America | Climate Town
Climate Town
B2
Môi trường
23:12
Who Actually Controls Gas Prices? | Climate Town
Climate Town
B2
Môi trường
Karaoke
30:55
Joe Rogan Doesn't Understand Graphs
Climate Town
B2
Môi trường
Karaoke
27:50
Your Food Is Lying To You | Climate Town
Climate Town
B2
Môi trường
Karaoke
21:27
It’s Time To Break Up With Our Gas Stoves | Climate Town
Climate Town